Опрос от разрабов BB III (сравнение между ББ1 и ББ2)

[Uff-East]

В Дискорд канале от разрабов ББ3 поступила просьба в ветке обсуждения ББ2 к игрокам которые играли и в первую часть и во вторую часть ББ поделиться своим мнением, ниже текст опроса, желающие могут проследовать на сам канал и там дать свои ответы.

Hi guys, I would like to ask for your feedback. I read a lot of comments saying people missed X or Y feature from BB1 in BB2. I personally think there is a lot of nostalgia in those feedback (which is not a bad thing) but I would like to know from your pov, if you played both games, what are the 3 (or more if you have more than 3) things you prefered in BB1 compared to BB2 and vice versa.

So

3 Things that were better in BB1
1 -
2 -
3 -

3 things that were better in BB2

1 -
2 -
3 -

Which of both games you prefered overall :

[Uff-East]

Если кому-то лень или нет дискорда, пишите сюда я опубликую 1 варик.

[raspel]

3 Things that were better in BB1
1 - 3D models and visual stuff: players improved their appearance with leveling; cheerleaders for every faction; visually different stadiums.
2 - Menu and lobby links and stats (you could one-click, for example, from schedule to team or coach page; you could see other coach page, his teams and stats).
3 - Hotkeys for actions (I used B for Blitz, there were, probably, some for Leap and Pass as well)

3 things that were better in BB2

1 - Reconnects. Best thing ever, ready to forgive everything for it.
2 - More elegant implementation of optional skills (small drop-out menus instead of huge tables of quarter-screen size).
3 - CTRL-switching mode with skill icons above players (actually, 2 of them: "all skills" and "gained skills"). Great thing.

Which of both games you prefered overall : BB2, mostly for reconnects (it outweights for me any downsides).

[laViper]

BB1
1)Khorne team
2)Players improved their appearance with leveling
3)Direct Call for match

BB2
1)Bretonnia team
2)Creating team with lvlups for some leagues
3)Bank rule (over 150 to team cost) and industment rule (underdog can use his money to add in total sum)

Which of both games you prefered overall : BB2 as a new one

[Nurdell]

Лень это конкретно мой случай.

Спойлер: Показать

1) Player miniature's armor upgraded on level-up.
2) BB1 camera changed angle when zoomed out.
3) 3d view showed miniature surrounded by dice and on bases.
4) I mildly preferred BB1 music, spikes on menu options and background, over blue BB2 menus.

1) Menu navigation got much easier
2) Kislev being newly added, and teams as DLCs
3) The pitch looks cleaner in BB2 without necessary tackle zones (I would still like an option for semi-transparent player skills though)

Still prefer BB1 more because I like the looks of all the old players (halflings, ogres, beast of nurgle as my top-3 changed for worse)

[KoMBINAToR]

BB1
1)Khorne team
2)Players improved their appearance with leveling
3)Direct Call for match
BB2
1)Bretonnia team
2)Creating team with lvlups for some leagues
3)Bank rule (over 150 to team cost) and industment rule (underdog can use his money to add in total sum)
Which of both games you prefered overall : BB2 as a new one

Лень, но я полностью солидарен с laViper, разве что в ББ2 мне апгрейды стадиона нравятся чуть больше, чем Bank & Inducement rules.

Надеюсь с этого опроса будет толк, и они хотя бы объединят фишечки из обоих игр, даже если и не добавят ничего нового (кроме новых правил разумеется).

[redgreenloko]

3 Things that were better in BB1
1 - timer flashing when it's less than X seconds remaining
2 - players of different levels look different so you can quicky find them on the pitch without the need of checking their skills (i play with skills hidden)
3 - name generator

3 things that were better in BB2

1 - reconnects
2 - graphics
3 -

Which of both games you prefered overall : BB1

[Qoom]

3 Things that were better in BB1
1- the game was better suited to the rules that were in place at the time. But in both cases, the rules were not fully implemented.
2- resource requirements
3- players of different levels look different so you can quicky find them on the pitch without the need of checking their skills

3 things that were better in BB2
1- reconnect
2- Creating team with level-ups for some leagues
3-

[pauletto]

3 Things that were better in BB1
1 - I was younger and USD was around 30 Rubles.  Endless Campaign mode!
2 - Varying look of the players with level progression.
3 - Leagues with ability to challenge any opponent with only one button.

3 things that were better in BB2

1 - Reconnect.
2 - Custom teams.
3 - Star players.

[Nurdell]

Разве в ББ1 не было реконнектов? Я же помню что там таймер от времени отсоединения считал 5 минут, вроде я даже один раз воспользовался этой функцией - и за мои стандартные 2 минуты переподключения модема вернулся в игру.

[kashey1983]

а слабо на французском обсуждать? 

[Nurdell]

А это уже вопрос к Уффисту - чего это он сразу на великий и могучий не перевёл вопросы "викторины". А мы только рады инглишом тряхнуть.

[Qoom]

Разве в ББ1 не было реконнектов?

только, если потеряно интернет-соединение. Если клиент выключился, то всё.

[Uff-East]

Короче объединил все ваши ответы, повторы исключил и запостил.

[Grindcore]

BB1
1)Khorne team
2)Players improved their appearance with leveling
3)Direct Call for match

BB2
1)Bretonnia team
2)Creating team with lvlups for some leagues
3)Bank rule (over 150 to team cost) and industment rule (underdog can use his money to add in total sum)

Which of both games you prefered overall : BB2 as a new one

я того же мнения